Four Signs Your Small Business Needs Outside General Counsel

At Williams Teusink, small businesses waiting too long to seek legal counsel is a problem we see all too often. They are trying to stay lean, keep overhead low, and bootstrap as much as possible. That instinct is understandable, and in early stages can make business sense. But at some point, what initially seems like a sensible way to conserve cash can become penny-wise and pound-foolish.

We often hear from businesses only after a dispute has escalated, a contract needs immediate attention, or another legal issue has become urgent. By then, the business may have fewer options, and addressing the problem can be considerably more difficult. Of course, most small businesses aren’t in a position to hire a full-time, in-house attorney. But the alternative doesn’t have to be waiting until something goes wrong and scrambling to find legal help.

That’s where outside general counsel, sometimes referred to as fractional general counsel, comes in. It’s an ongoing relationship with an attorney or law firm that understands your business, knows your goals and can help address legal issues before they become more serious and expensive.

So when is the right time to establish that relationship? Here are four signs your business may already be there.

1. You’ve run into a legal problem your team isn’t equipped to handle

One of the clearest signs a business needs outside general counsel is when a legal issue arises and nobody on the team is equipped to deal with it.

That might be a demand letter. A dispute with a customer or vendor. The threat of litigation. Or a scenario where you’re suddenly asked to respond to something with significant legal consequences and no one inside the company has the appropriate skill set, the time, or both.

We see this more often than we would like. A business calls and something is already on fire. The situation has gotten bad enough they need a lawyer to jump in immediately — sometimes within days — to file a pleading, enter an appearance, respond to a letter, or take some other action fast.

When a company reaches out in that posture, the lawyer has to get up to speed immediately: understand the business, review the documents, learn the facts, sort out the timeline, and establish the relationship. That is a problem. Sometimes there simply is not enough runway to do that responsibly. In those cases, firms may have to decline the representation, not because they do not want to help, but because they cannot do it effectively on that timetable.

That is a terrible position for a business to be in.

If you already have outside general counsel, the dynamic changes. There is already a relationship. There are communication channels. There is trust. Your lawyer already understands your business well enough to move quickly when something goes sideways.

The better move is to establish the relationship before the emergency.

2. Legal issues are becoming a time suck that pulls you away from growth

In the early entrepreneurial stage, almost every business owner does almost everything.

That is normal. In fact, when I was helping build my own law firm, I did everything too! I handled QuickBooks entries. I dealt with social media. I ran down to the courthouse to file motions. Early on, that is part of the deal. You are small, you are lean, and you are wearing a lot of different hats to try and make it all work.

But at a certain point, doing everything yourself becomes inefficient. 

When founders and early employees are spending increasing amounts of time dealing with contracts, disputes, policies, hiring issues, or legal questions, that is time they are not spending developing the product, closing deals, serving clients, or growing the business. At that point, the real question becomes:

Could we make more money by spending a little money? For many businesses, the answer is yes.

A good outside general counsel relationship can create real value in two ways. First, legal professionals are usually going to be better at legal work than non-lawyers trying to figure it out on the fly. Second, the business gets back the opportunity cost of leadership spending time on non-core functions.

That is when the math starts to make sense.

3. Legal questions are starting to come up on a semi-regular basis

Another sign is when legal issues stop being a rare occurrence.

If you find yourself saying every few weeks, “I wish I had somebody I could run this by,” that is probably your answer.

Maybe a customer sends over a complex agreement. Maybe a vendor wants changes to a contract. Maybe you are hiring people and have employment questions. Maybe a dispute pops up that hasn’t turned into litigation yet, but could. Or maybe you just keep running into situations where you wish you had someone you could run things by.

At that point, the issue is no longer whether your business ever has legal needs. It clearly does.

The question becomes whether it makes more sense to keep handling those issues in a piecemeal, reactive way — asking for recommendations, calling around, meeting lawyers cold, trying to figure out who does what — or whether it makes more sense to have an established relationship already in place.

That is one of the biggest benefits of outside general counsel. You are not starting from scratch every time something comes up. You already have somebody who understands your company and can either handle the issue directly or quickly route it to the right person. And that matters.

One advantage of working with a firm like ours is when an issue crosses over from general business advice into litigation or another specialty area, there is already a team in place. The problem does not have to leave the relationship. It can be addressed within it.

4. If you’re already asking whether you need outside general counsel, you probably do

This may be the simplest sign of all.

There is no magic headcount. There is no exact revenue threshold. There is no universal rule that once you hit a certain number of employees or a certain number of dollars in sales, you automatically need outside general counsel.

But if your leadership team is already asking the question and wondering whether it would make sense to bring in outside legal support, it usually means the need is already there.

By the time businesses start asking that question, they are often already feeling the pressure:

  • legal tasks are becoming distracting,
  • questions are arising more often,
  • growth is creating complexity,
  • or they are worried about what happens if a dispute hits tomorrow.

That is usually the moment to act. And if your company is measuring annual revenue in the millions, you should almost certainly be thinking about it.

Again, this is not about jumping straight from no lawyer to a $150,000 or $200,000 in-house salary position. For many small and midsize businesses, that does not make sense. But investing a fraction of that amount each year to establish an ongoing relationship with outside general counsel can be a far more practical approach, especially when it gives you both legal support and the confidence that comes from knowing somebody already has your back.

The bottom line

Outside general counsel is not just for massive companies with big legal departments. It can be an efficient and practical fit for small businesses that are moving out of the pure bootstrap phase and into a more established stage of growth.

The biggest mistake I see is businesses waiting until something forces the issue.

Do not wait until the demand letter arrives. Do not wait until the contract is on your desk and the other side wants it signed immediately. Do not wait until a dispute has already snowballed into litigation.

Do it before something is on fire.

If your business is growing, if legal issues are coming up more often, or if you are already wondering whether it is time, there is a good chance it is. To learn more about how we can help, click here.